Analysis Comparative study

The Institute for Crime & Justice Policy Research (ICPR), based at Birkbeck, University of London, led a comparative research and policy project to understand the causes and consequences of over-incarceration worldwide. ICPR has worked with a large network of NGOs, academic researchers and practitioners spanning this diverse selection of countries. ICPR partnered with Prison Insider in the latter stages of the project to shed light on aspects of prisoners’ lived experience in custody before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. The project team collaborated to gather national and international experts’ insights, and to facilitate a continuing global conversation around the key research findings.

The project focuses on five main themes :

  • Changing patterns of imprisonment
  • Sentencing
  • Pre-trial justice
  • Prisons and health
  • COVID-19 and prisons

Discover our expert’s insights and filmed conversations to understand the use o imprisonnement around the globe.

Pre-trial justice

kenya_gilbert.jpg

Kenya

finding Kafka in the criminal justice system

Gilbert M. Omware, Defence lawyer and criminal justice researcher, currently working as a Managing Partner for Mitullah, Shako and Associates Advocates LLP. discusses the injustices faced by vulnerable groups in pretrial detention.

Read Gilbert’s insights.

madhurima_dhanuka_icpr.jpg

India

Remote hearings and the rights of accused persons

Madhurima Dhanuka, Programme Head at the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative in India, discusses the impact of remote hearings on fair trials.

Read Madhurima’s insights.

cadran_panopticon.jpg

Europe

the long road to human dignity

Maïté De Rue, Legal Adviser to the Open Society Justice Initiative, discusses the overuse of pre-trial detention in Europe and its consequences.

Read Maïté’s insights.

escalier.webp

Europe

towards a binding legal framework for places of detention

Saskia Bricmont, a native of Ath in Belgium, has been a member of the Greens and the European Free Alliance (EFA) at the European Parliament since May 2019. She advocates for an open, altruistic and tolerant society and supports those who fight for democracy, human rights and social justice. Here, Saskia discusses a possible binding European framework for minimum standards on places of detention.

Read Saskia’s insights.

visages.jpg

World

Rehumanising pretrial justice

Jago Russell, chief executive of the organisation Fair Trials, discusses the impacts of pretrial justice.

Read Jago’s insights.

filming.jpg

Filmed discussions on pre-trial justice

Directed by Camille Laufer

Europe: questioning the use of pre-trial detention

Will remote hearings and digital justice become the norm for pre-trial decisions in Europe?

Laure Baudrihaye-Gérard, European legal director of Fair Trials, a worldwide criminal justice watchdog, and Diana Riba i Giner MEP (Greens/EFA), discuss the potential normalisation of digital hearings in the wake of the pandemic, and the importance of research evidence in creating solutions to end over-use of pre-trial detention.


Latin America: pre-trial detention and access to justice

Prison overcrowding in Latin America - is it caused by over-use of pre-trial detention?

A discussion about rights under threat and the consequences for women, people of colour, and marginalised groups, with Isabel Roby, legal and policy officer, Fair Trials (Latin America) and Hugo Leonardo, president of the Brazilian defence lawyers’ network, Instituto de Defesa do Direito de Defesa.

Sentencing

noirblanczebre.jpg

England and Wales

short prison sentences, directions for future reform

Helen Mills, Head of Programmes at the Centre for Crime and Justice Studies, discusses the vexed problem of short prison sentences.

Read Helen Mills’ insights.

lumiere.webp

The Netherlands

"Going Dutch" – taking care of forensic mental healthcare

Michiel van der Wolf, psychologist and a lawyer, discusses the Dutch approach for dealing with those considered as mentally disordered offenders.

Read Michiel’s insights.

birds_on_a_line.jpg

United States

surge in life sentences

Ashley Nellis, Ph.D. is a Senior Research Analyst at the Washington DC-based NGO, The Sentencing Project, which has been active in the struggle to reform American law and practice on life sentences.

Read Ashley Nellis’s insights.

photo.ny

United States

there’s an aging crisis in New York’s prisons and we need to solve it

Rodney Holcombe, New York State Director for Criminal Justice Reform at FWD.us, explains the aging crisis and why parole reform could reduce racial disparities in parole outcomes, and save the state millions of dollars annually. 

Read Rodney’s insights.

thailande.jpg

Thailand

the overcriminalization of meth, a failed moral crusade

Pascal Tanguay is an independent consultant who has lived in Thailand for the past 17 years. Here, Pascal discusses the overcriminalization of meth-related crimes in Thailand and its consequences.

Read Pascal’s insights.

petty_footprint_nb.jpg

Africa

a regional campaign to decriminalise petty offences

Louise Edwards, Director of Research and Programmes at the African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum, based in Cape Town, South Africa, reflects on the works and challenges of the Regional Campaign to Decriminalise Petty Offences.

Read Louise’s insights.

main_ombres.jpg

World

Life imprisonment: a sentence in dire need of reform

Olivia Rope, Executive Director of Penal Reform International (PRI), discusses life sentences, a key priority area for PRI.

Read Olivia’s insights.

filming.jpg

Filmed discussion on sentencing

directed by Camille Laufer

South Africa: criminalizing poverty and homelessness

Can homelessness lead to prison in South Africa?

Derrick Thulani Ndlovu discusses South Africa’s justice system and prison conditions with Danielle Louw, of Ndifuna Ukwazi (‘Dare to know’), a social justice activism group based in Cape Town.

Health and COVID-19

original_pink_ballon.jpg

United States

addressing the structural inequalities underlying a failing prison health system

Dr. Venters discusses the problems in prison health system in the United States and ways to address them.

Read Homer’s insights.

jackson_david_8fk_pjtfjfy_unsplash.jpg

Brazil

an obstacle course for prisoners' families in the pandemic

Maria Teresa dos Santos is the chair of the Associação de Amigos e Familiares de Pessoas em Privação de Liberdade (Association of friends and family members of people in deprivedation of liberty) in the state of Minas Gerais. Prison Insider has interviewed Maria Teresa her in September 2020.

Read Maria Teresa’s interview.

redflowers.webp

Brazil

the vital work of the Public Defenders’ Office in a public health crisis

Patrick Cacicedo is a Public Defender based in São Paulo.Patrick holds a PhD from the University of São Paulo (USP), and is a researcher in prison matters. Here, Patrick reflects on the work of the Public Defenders’ Officeg and the alarming situation of Brazilian prisons during the current health crisis.

Read Patrick’s insights.

mud_africa.jpg

Africa

health beyond epidemics

Frédéric Le Marcis is an anthropologist. He focuses on epidemic responses in prison environment in different African countries.

Read Frédéric’s insights.

oublies_ok2.jpg

Africa

informal governance and healthcare access in prison

Carole Berrih, a lawyer specialising in public law, is the director of Synergies Coopération. Her research focuses on the role of prisoners in the maintenance of order in Nigerian prisons.

Read Carole’s insights.

filming.jpg

Filmed discussions on COVID-19

Directed by Camille Laufer

Brazil: the impact of COVID-19 on family links and prison monitoring

Family links and independent monitoring systems in Brazil’s prisons – what are the effects of the pandemic?

Realities on the ground are discussed by Rafael Godoi, a sociologist and researcher at Rio’s Universidade Federal (UFRJ), and Alessandra Félix, an activist from Brazil’s north-eastern state of Ceará, member of the group Vozes (‘Voices of mothers and relatives’) and of Brazil’s Frente pelo Desencarceramento (decarceration front).


Solitary confinement, COVID-19 and mental health impacts

Dr Sharon Shalev is an international expert on the use and consequences of solitary confinement. She is Research Associate at the Centre for Criminology at Oxford University, and manages an informational website www.solitaryconfinement.org. Sharon authored the Sourcebook on Solitary Confinement, a practitioner’s guide to the health effects of solitary confinement, a book on the US ‘Supermax’ prisons, and reports on solitary confinement practices in England and Wales and in New Zealand. Nuno Pontes is an expert on incarceration and related human rights issues with over thirty years’ experience in the field. His knowledge of American solitary/supermax practices drives his work and activism both in the USA, and in Europe where he has been a member of the European Prison Observatory since 2013.

Stand by us

Monthly donation

Take action
Produce
Share our content
Contribute
mockups_devices_en.png