Security, order, and discipline
Security, order, and discipline
Security functions are fulfilled by
- the prison service
- the police or gendarmerie
- private companies
The department of security within the Ministry of the Interior is responsible for the management of prison security.
The Ministry of the Interior has given responsibility for the external prison security to private companies. Article 63 of the prison regulations, however, states that “the external security of establishments is the responsibility of The State Security Forces and Corps (FFCCSE) or, where applicable, the police forces of the autonomous communities”.
Some prison facilities, units or cells implement high-security measures
Isolation cells, also known as high security, hold prisoners considered to be dangerous.
The Herrera de La Mancha prison, built in 1979, was one of the first maximum security prisons built in Spain. The Alicante II prison is one of the most secure facilities.
Some of the enhanced security measures employed are:
- Individual cells
- Solitary walking time
- Reduced contact with wardens
- Frequent cell changes
There is no time limit to prisoners being confined under this type of regime.
Prisoners are classified according to their supposed level of dangerousness
Article 63 of the General Penitentiary Organic Law allows for individual treatment according to how dangerous the prisoner is considered to be. The classification takes into account the criminal history, personality, family and social situation and the length of the sentence.
The classification of prisoners is revised
every three or six months
The classification is reviewed every three or six months for “first grade” prisoners (article 65 of the General Penitentiary Organic Law).
The methods of body search employed are pat-down, strip search and body cavity search. The person carrying out the search is clearly identifiable. Cells are not equipped with cameras. Searches are not filmed. Strip searches are carried out in a dedicated room.
Body cavity searches are conducted by a physician
Body cavity searches are carried out by officers of the same gender as the prisoner. They are carried out in a closed room with no other prisoners present and, as far as possible, in a way that is respectful to the prisoner (article 68 of the royal decree 190/1996).
Relatives who enter the prison are searched using the following methods
- electronic devices (scanners, electronic security detectors, etc.)
- strip searc
Visitors are required to pass through an electronic security detector gate. Article 45 of the 190/1996 decree allows visitors to be strip-searched if they are believed to be concealing a prohibited object. The visitor is refused entry if they refuse to be searched.
Professionals who enter the prison are searched using the following methods
electronic devices (scanners, electronic security detectors, etc.)
Wardens, social workers, lawyers, chaplains and other qualified persons undergo an electronic security check.
Methods of constraint (handcuffs, shackles) are used after an incident, when transferring a prisoner to a high security area.
Minors in the Sogradio and Tierras de Oria prisons have reported being slapped and hit by staff. The CPT notes the use of mechanical constraint on agitated minors. Some minors at the Tierras de Orias prison were immobilised on their stomach while attached to a bed for several hours. They were not allowed access to a toilet.
Security staff carry
non-lethal weapons (truncheons, tasers, tear gas, etc.)
Staff are authorised to resort to firearms in the event of imminent danger to people or to the establishment.
A special intervention unit is in charge of restoring order
Article 72 of the prison regulations allows that in the event of serious disorder or imminent danger to persons or belongings, the prison governor can call upon security forces to intervene (“Fuerzas de Seguridad de guardia”, FFCCSE). These organisations are permitted to use firearms. The use of firearms is controlled by legislation for the FFCCSE and by the General Penitentiary Organic Law.
The Observatory of the Penal System and Human Rights (OSPDH at the University of Barcelona) has noted continued abuse by wardens, such as damage to the personal effects of prisoners.
Breaches of discipline are clearly defined in writing
Article 42 of the penitentiary law of 1979 allows for various disciplinary sanctions:
- Solitary confinement, for a maximum of 14 days
- Solitary confinement at the weekend, for a maximum of seven weekends
- Denial of exit permits, for a maximum of two months
- Limit on telephone communication, for a maximum of one month
- Denial of walks and communal activities, for a maximum of one month.
- Formal warnings
Disciplinary offences are investigated
in most cases
The investigation file must state the identification number of the investigating officer and the post they hold. The names of other parties involved in the investigation are sometimes included.
The decision to apply a disciplinary sanction must be subject to an adversarial debate
in most cases
The prisoner has three working days, starting from the day when they receive notification of the sanction, to present their defence in writing or to appear before the investigator and testify verbally.
Prisoners are allowed to be assisted by a lawyer
A lawyer can assist the prisoner in the preparation of their defence. The lawyer is not permitted to be present at the disciplinary committee.
Every disciplinary sanction is delivered by a collegial body: the disciplinary committee. Article 276 of the prison regulations requires the disciplinary committee to be presided over by the prison governor and to consist of the following people: the deputy director of security, an in-house lawyer, a head of department and a representative of the prison staff (chosen annually).
Prisoners may appeal against disciplinary sanctions
Appeals are made to the prison governor, who informs the judicial authority. A copy in a sealed envelope is returned to the prisoner.
Disciplinary sanctions can be imposed as a collective punishment
Solitary confinement can be used as
- security measure
Solitary confinement is used as a preventative measure to “protect the life or physical integrity of the prisoner and to maintain order in the establishment”. It is sometimes used arbitrarily.
Prisoners who have committed sexual offences or those who belong to the LGBTI community can be placed in isolation to guarantee their safety. They can also be placed - unofficially - in the infirmary or in the new arrivals area. Officials of state bodies who are incarcerated are placed in separate areas for their own protection.
Disciplinary use of solitary confinement (article 42 of the penitentiary law) is applied in the event of gross misconduct (aggression, violence, persistent and serious disturbance of communal life).
A prisoner can be placed in solitary confinement if they are found in possession of prohibited items (weapons, controlled substances…).
Solitary confinement is decided
- at a magistrate’s order
- by the prison governor
- by guards
The judge must approve the solitary confinement order when it exceeds 14 days (article 76 of the penitentiary law). The prison governor can authorise a prisoner being placed in solitary confinement (article 75 of the penitentiary law) without defence or appeal.
The duration for placement in solitary confinement is limited
yes, for disciplinary measures
Article 42 of the penitentiary law regulates the length of time that a prisoner can remain in solitary confinement for disciplinary reasons. The period of isolation cannot exceed 14 days or seven consecutive weekends for one disciplinary offence. The period can extend to a maximum of 42 days for multiple disciplinary offences.
Solitary confinement can be extended
The CPT observed that in several establishments, consecutive periods of solitary confinement for disciplinary reasons were being implemented after a one-day break.
Solitary confinement is implemented in a dedicated unit that exists in all establishments. Cells have a surface area of around 10m2. They are equipped with a metal bed and table secured to the wall, a shelving unit and a chair. The sanitary facilities (WC, washbasin and shower) are situated within the cell. The CPT consider the lighting and ventilation to be adequate. The units are equipped with a small gym, an education room and a courtyard for exercise1.
European Committee for the Prevention of Torture, “Report on the visit from 27 September to 10 October 2016”, 2017, p.34. ↩
Prisoners placed in solitary confinement can spend three hours outside of the cell per day. They are allowed to spend their walking time with another prisoner and in exceptional cases, activities can include up to five people. The courtyards do not provide a welcoming environment: grey, with no decoration or vegetation. The horizontal view is limited to ten metres.
Prisoners placed in solitary confinement for disciplinary reasons are initially denied access to cultural or sporting activities. Access is gradually reintroduced to allow the prisoners to demonstrate their good behaviour.
Prisoners undergoing sanctions are denied visits from their loved ones. Prisoners must be informed of the duration of any ban on telephone calls.